Tuesday, April 8, 2014

Review: Queen Elizabeth's Daughter: A Novel of Elizabeth I by Anne Clinard Barnhill


Queen Elizabeth's Daughter: A Novel of Elizabeth I by Anne Clinard Barnhill 

Published March 18th 2014 by St. Martin's Griffin
Paperback, 384 pages
Series: Stand-Alone
Genre: Historical Fiction
Heat Rating: Kissing to some steamy

Amazon | The Book Depository Goodreads


Summary from Goodreads

From the author of At the Mercy of the Queen comes the gripping tale of Mary Shelton, Elizabeth I’s young cousin and ward, set against the glittering backdrop of the Elizabethan court.

Mistress Mary Shelton is Queen Elizabeth’s favorite ward, enjoying every privilege the position affords. The queen loves Mary like a daughter, and, like any good mother, she wants her to make a powerful match. The most likely prospect: Edward de Vere, Earl of Oxford. But while Oxford seems to be everything the queen admires: clever, polished and wealthy, Mary knows him to be lecherous, cruel, and full of treachery. No matter how hard the queen tries to push her into his arms, Mary refuses.

Instead, Mary falls in love with a man who is completely unsuitable. Sir John Skydemore is a minor knight with little money, a widower with five children. Worst of all, he’s a Catholic at a time when Catholic plots against Elizabeth are rampant. The queen forbids Mary to wed the man she loves. When the young woman, who is the queen’s own flesh and blood, defies her, the couple finds their very lives in danger as Elizabeth’s wrath knows no bounds.


It has been such a long time since I have read a historical fiction based on Tudors Era that I couldn't wait when I saw the new release of Queen Elizabeth's Daughter to come out!

Mary Shelton is Queen Elizabeth's favorite ward, having been under the queens care ever since her mother died when she was only 3 years old - she lives the life of privilege that her position offers. Queen Elizabeth loves Mary as if she was her very own flesh and blood. Therefore like any good mother, she want's what's best for Mary, to make her a powerful match. The first person that comes to mind that has title and money is the Earl of Oxford who the queen seems to be quiet fond off. Too bad that Mary saw the darker side of the man and want's nothing to do with him.

Mary is perfectly content with being the queens maid and by her side until Sir John Skydemore shows up in her life. A knight who is a widower with five children and little money. Not to mention, Sir John is also Catholic and the Queen is currently in turmoil with Catholics plotting against her.

Interesting story. I really liked how history was weaved into the plot and became part of the story and how it affected the Queen and Mary alike. It was very interesting to read about the time era and it wasn't completely romanticized. Like the fact that the castle would eventually stink so bad that they would have to move through the seasons into a different place to live because it was a different kind of times.

What I really liked in this story is Mary. She had a very pure heart even if her love and devotion to the Queen had felt quiet overwhelming at times. As evident at the end of the book when she makes a sacrifice of some sort in order to please her Queen. I was pretty floored by her love for the queen.

What I had a hard time with in this book is some of the character. Earl of Oxford was a nasty man with ill-fitted intentions. I did not like his actions towards Mary and then him trying to drag her name through the mud when she went on rejecting him. In one scene I felt he got what he deserved.

The Queen left me scratching my head at times as well, her hot and cold temper left me cringing at times. The writing was something also to get use to, a lot of over-dramatic scenes and conversations. Including some of Mary's reactions towards Earl of Oxford, at times it sounded like she wouldn't have minded him asking the Queen for her hand - even if he was a terrible, terrible man. It read oddly at times but I had managed to by pass all of that because I did enjoy the story and the slow blooming romance between Sir John and Mary.

I also enjoyed Author's note in the end that explained which parts was fiction and facts from the research that she had done before writing the book.

13 comments:

  1. Hmmm over dramatic scenes? Not sure if I would like this one or not but I do love this era. I might have to keep this one in mind.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I love when historical fiction has some basis in fact. I'm sorry parts of this didn't work for you, but that you liked it overall.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I don't think I've ever read something like that even if I read more and more historical romances... Not sure it's for me. Maybe because I always have the Tudor in head, and I prefer my stories a little more light.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Oh Bess, just let the girl go, which I hope she does ;)

    ReplyDelete
  5. It seems most everyone has read a Tudor novel at some point except me, so I definitely need to pick one up soon. Thanks for reminding me, Lily!

    ReplyDelete
  6. What I love about historicals is the steamy kissing and extremely fun and malicious plotting. Other than that? Well.. histroicals aren't my favorite, but I'm so glad that you enjoy them. As for this one, I'm sorry you didn't exactly love all the characters and had some problems with writing. I am glad though that you enjoyed the romance and the book as a whole :) Great review, Lily!

    ReplyDelete
  7. I was once a huge fan of Tudor novels. If this is a thing you'd like to try, you should seek out some of Philippa Greggory's novels. The lady knows a thing or two. :)

    ReplyDelete
  8. I'm glad you were able to find a few things to enjoy in this one, Lily. I, too, love the Tudor era but haven't read any in a very long time. Thanks for sharing your thoughts.

    ReplyDelete
  9. I rarely read historical fiction like this anymore, but really want to. I love the fact that she went over her research like that in the end.

    ReplyDelete
  10. I haven't read historical fiction in years, but I used to adore it! Your review has me thinking it might be time to re-visit that genre. I LOVE that the author's note at the end included what was fact and what was fiction -- that has me so intrigued. Great review!

    ReplyDelete
  11. I loved this time period and Mary always fascinated me. I love when an author weaves historical facts into fiction. While I don't think this one is for me, I would have issue with the overdone drama and flow you mentioned.

    ReplyDelete
  12. I love a good historical book from time to time. And the period is just awesome. Mary sounds great too.

    ReplyDelete
  13. I really enjoy historical fiction sometimes, but it can be hit or miss because of the setting. Great review! I really love your content descriptors, btw. Thanks for stopping by! :)

    Tressa @ Tressa's Wishful Endings

    ReplyDelete